New Hire Checklist: What to Look Out For in Applicants

Hiring the right employees is a critical task that can greatly impact the success of any organization. However, attracting and hiring top talent can be a challenging process, one that requires skillful outreach, recruitment marketing, as well as a careful evaluation of applicants to identify those who possess the potential for greatness and avoid potential pitfalls.

Our focus will be on recognizing the early signs of a great hire and identifying warning signals that may indicate a potential hiring disaster in the making.

As an employer, your primary goal is to build a team of skilled and dedicated professionals who can contribute to your company's growth and profitability. To help you make well-informed hiring decisions, we delve into the red flags you should watch out for when evaluating candidates. These indicators provide crucial insights into whether an applicant is a good-quality hire or whether they will engage in misconduct that will make them unsuitable for the role and harm your organization's culture.

By following this checklist, you can streamline your hiring process, enhance your decision-making, and ultimately build a strong and competent team.

The Challenges of Finding Great Talent

As organizations strive for growth and success, finding, attracting, and retaining exceptional talent has become an increasingly complex endeavor. In the pursuit of building a strong and capable workforce, employers encounter various challenges that require careful navigation.

Here are some employers’ pain points when trying to find great talent:

• Talent Shortage: Scarcity of skilled candidates in the job market poses difficulties in finding the right fit for specific roles.
• High Turnover Rates: Hiring mistakes can lead to increased turnover, impacting productivity and incurring additional costs.
• Time Constraints: Today’s talent acquisition teams are understaffed and tasked with doing more with less. Beyond recruiters, however, the hiring process demands significant time and effort, from hiring team members, diverting resources from other essential tasks.
• Identifying Cultural Fit: Ensuring candidates align with the company's culture and values is crucial for a harmonious work environment.
• Passive Candidates: Convincing passive candidates, who are already employed, to consider a job change can be challenging.
• Employer Branding: A weak employer brand can deter potential applicants and hinder recruitment efforts.
• Competition from Other Employers: To attract top talent, employers must showcase unique benefits and competitive compensation packages.
• Bias and Discrimination: Unconscious bias in hiring can hinder diversity and inclusion efforts, impacting the overall hiring process.

In navigating these challenges, employers can greatly benefit from partnering with an industry-leading online screening solution like Fama.

New Hire Checklist: Red Flags to Watch Out For

When evaluating potential candidates for a position, it is essential for employers to be vigilant for early warning signs that may indicate potential issues down the line.

“Did you know, in 2018, ninety-six percent of employers conducted one or more types of employment background screening, and this percentage increased by one point in subsequent years.”

- Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA)

A well-structured New Hire Checklist helps employers identify both positive indicators of a great hire and the red flags that may signal a potential disaster in the making. By incorporating items in this checklist in your hiring process, you can make more informed decisions and secure candidates who align with the company's goals and values.

Here are 8 major red flags that employers should be mindful when evaluating potential candidates:

1. Refusal of Background Check Consent

Candidates who hesitate or outright refuse to provide consent for a background check raise concerns about what they might be concealing. Transparency is essential in the hiring process, and a candidate's unwillingness to undergo a background check could indicate potential issues.

2. Negative or Unenthusiastic References

When speaking with previous employers or references, if the feedback about the candidate is predominantly negative or lacks enthusiasm, it may indicate performance issues, conflicts, or a lack of commitment to their previous roles.

3. Frequent Job Changes

A candidate's resume marked by numerous short-term jobs could be a red flag. Frequent job changes might suggest a lack of stability, an inability to thrive in long-term roles, or dissatisfaction with previous positions.

4. Misrepresentation of Previous Jobs

Discrepancies between the candidate's stated work history and the results of a background check may point to dishonesty. It is crucial to ensure that the candidate's claims align with the verified information.

5. Insufficient Relevant Experience

A candidate who lacks the necessary skills or relevant experience for the position may struggle to meet expectations and perform effectively in the role.

6. Criminal History

While having a criminal history does not and should not automatically disqualify a candidate, employers should carefully assess whether the nature of the past offense is relevant to the role and if it poses any potential risks.

7. Online Activity and Social Media Presence

‍Research shows that 3 out of 4 hiring managers review candidates’ social media profiles during the hiring process and 8 in 10 decided not to hire someone based on their findings. While hiring managers doing these social and online searches aren’t compliant and can lead to biased decisions and discrimination lawsuits, the idea of leveraging candidates’ every day behavior, which is often reflected online, is helpful. Leveraging a 3rd party to conduct a prudent review of a candidate's social media profiles to gauge their behavior can uncover inappropriate or unprofessional content that could reflect negatively on the candidate and the company's image.

Talent acquisition experts who overlook these warning signs risk making poor hiring decisions, leading to employee misconduct issues, reduced team moral, and increased turnover. On the other hand, those who diligently incorporate the New Hire Checklist and leverage comprehensive background screenings, such as those provided by Fama, can make well-informed choices.

What to Look for in an Employee Background Screening Service

Selecting the right employee background screening service is a critical decision for employers looking to make informed hiring choices and maintain a secure work environment. When considering potential screening partners, it is essential to focus on key qualities that enhance the hiring process without overshadowing the main goal of finding the best candidates.

Here are essential factors to consider when choosing a background screening service:

Comprehensive Screening Solutions

A reliable screening service should offer a broad range of screening options, including criminal history checks, employment verification, education verification, online and social media screening, and more. These comprehensive solutions ensure a thorough evaluation of candidates.

Compliance with Regulations

Employers should prioritize screening services that adhere to legal and regulatory standards, safeguarding both the employer's and the applicant's rights throughout the process. Fama is dedicated to maintaining compliance and transparency.

Accurate and Timely Reporting

Time is of the essence in the hiring process. A reputable service employs advanced technology to deliver accurate and timely screening results, expediting the decision-making process.

Customizable Solutions

Each organization's hiring needs and company cultures are unique, and a flexible screening service offers personalized screening packages that align with specific requirements and budget considerations.

Cutting-Edge Technology

Advanced technology, including artificial intelligence, can equip screening providers and employers with valuable insights into a candidate's background and behavior. The commitment to leveraging such tools ensures a deeper understanding of potential hires more efficiently, accurately, and cost-effectively.

Final Thoughts

This checklist serves as a valuable tool for employers in their quest to find, evaluate, and hire the right talent while avoiding potential hiring pitfalls. By paying attention to early signs of great hires and recognizing red flags of misconduct, employers can make well-informed decisions that lead to a successful and productive workforce.

When it comes to modern employee background screening services, partnering with a reputable provider is essential. Fama stands out as a reliable ally, offering comprehensive online screening solutions, advanced technology, and a commitment to compliance. Employers can benefit from Fama's ability to identify workplace misconduct in a way that increases candidate quality and does so with timely and accurate reporting.

By leveraging the New Hire Checklist and the support of Fama, employers can confidently navigate the hiring process, ensuring they build a skilled and trustworthy team that drives their organization's growth, compliance, and profitability.

See additional insights from Fama Labs: How Online Screening Can Impact Quality of Hire. Get Report Now!

‍